I read so many books in September and so I’m really delighted to be bringing you another set of three reviews and wrapping up my September ARC reads… over halfway through November. Nothing like a timely review, right? Seriously though, How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates by Shailee Thompson was so fantastic and out of my comfort zone so I can’t wait to talk about it more. The Matchmaker’s Cottage by Kat Sloane is exactly within my comfort zone and yet, I can’t put my finger on why it’s not my new favorite book of the year. Then we have If Not You by Ellen O’Clover, whose first book last year I adored and I wish that I’d felt the same about this one. And finally, I DNF’d Vera Stein is Completely Fine by Julie Murphy and I wish I understood myself enough to know why that book wasn’t landing for me when every piece of it should have been. So let’s get into it, shall we?

How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates by Shailee Thompson
To say that this book is out of my comfort zone feels like such a massive understatement that I’m not even sure what could fully explain to you that this book was a risk for me. But it was a risk that paid off. Do I think that you will enjoy this book more if you like slasher movies? Maybe, because then you might understand some of the references that went right over my head. But given how much I enjoyed this book, I’m really not sure you could enjoy it more than me. This book has grown on me so much in the time since I read it too, which is always a good sign. Oh, I should explain what this book is even about.
Essentially, Jamie and her best friend, Laurie, go to this speed dating event and then all of the lights go off and when they turn back on, there is a dead body. Chaos ensues. Jamie knows how to survive a slasher because she’s literally writing her dissertation on slasher movies and rom coms so she and Laurie are determined that they’ll survive. In the meantime, there are two gentlemen that Jamie met during the speed dating process that she’s intrigued by.
I really liked the friendship between Laurie and Jamie. I really loved the humor in the book. The audiobook was fantastic in my opinion for getting the tone correct. I don’t think I would have enjoyed this as much if I’d been reliant on my own brain to capture the tone, honestly. I also really wound up enjoying the romance, but that is something I’ve enjoyed more with distance. In the moment, I think the romance is what I dinged the book for because I wanted more of it. Now, with distance, I think the book is actually so well paced and so well balanced between all of the elements. Anyway, I’m so delighted by this book that I’ve requested and been approved for the next book from Thompson, which is a delight!
The Matchmaker’s Cottage by Kit Sloane
If you’re looking for a romance that gives you depth of character like Kate Clayborn, I think you’ll like this one. I wanted to connect with it a little more, but I’m not really sure why I didn’t. Although, I have DNF’d Emma a half dozen times and this is a gender flipped retelling, so maybe I should just be glad that I actually enjoyed this one at all.
This book is about childhood best friends, Julia and Ethan, who had a falling out and haven’t spoken in years. Now Julia is running a bed and breakfast that Ethan is suddenly convinced is the perfect backdrop for two celebrity clients to stage a romance and maybe even fall in love for real. Ethan needs this win and Julia needs the money, so even though she’s reluctant to let Ethan back into her life, she agrees.
What this book does well is the setting and the melancholy. For some reason though, I didn’t manage to emotionally connect, which is what I’ve been needing lately. And that could definitely be on me and not on the book! I do really love a book where one of the characters is running a bed and breakfast or a cafe. Just really being part of the community is what I like about it. There is some lingering grief in this book because Julia lost her mom years prior, but if that could be difficult for you to pick up, I would hold off until you’re in a good place.
If Not You by Ellen O’Clover
I fell into O’Clover’s debut so easily last year and that’s the experience I was expecting to have with If Not You, but instead, I found myself at a remove and it took me quite a while to get emotionally invested in the characters. However, I did get emotionally invested in these characters, so that’s definitely a win. I feel terrible for saying that I didn’t like Mattie because I hate to be that person who doesn’t enjoy a book as much because she doesn’t like the FMC, and yet, that’s the truth! There was something about Mattie that just felt so frustrating because she was so guarded that it made it difficult for the romantic plot to progress even though Campbell was like, genuinely nice. But!! That’s the point of this book. Let me actually explain what this book is about…
Essentially Mattie and Campbell were interns together and there was only one permanent position. This created a work rivalry, think The Hating Game, but now it’s been a decade and even though they are now at two entirely different companies, Mattie is still competing with Campbell, only now they’re actually competing for the same account so they really ARE competitors. For some reason, this hotel account is dragging these two teams to a couple different resorts so that they can be better equipped to write the copy.
This book didn’t land for me for a variety of reasons, but I do think that competitors at work needs more of a light hearted tone because otherwise I’m thinking about bills and work and stress in a way that just doesn’t make for a pleasant reading experience. Nevertheless, I ddi like this book overall, it just took me a bit to get there. So hopefully if you pick this up, you’ll have an even better experience with it than I did.
DNF Review: Vera Stein is Fine by Julie Murphy
Y’all, I wanted to love this book so much, but for some reason, I felt exclusively stressed out by it and never managed to fall into the book. And by for some reason, I think it’s pretty much what I mentioned above: If I’m spending more time thinking about financial struggles in the fiction I’m reading, then the book isn’t going to work for me because I think about my own finances TOO MUCH. But I do think that one day when I’m financially stable, maybe I’d be willing to go back and try this book again. Maybe.
Closing Thoughts
Overall, three solid reads, but my favorite was definitely How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates. Have you read any of these three? Are you planning to pick any of them up? Let me know!
xx